“The writer should be the one to click it”

The beauty of Web publishing, and the specific beauty of TechCrunch, is that the only barrier between bloggers’ overflowing brains and readers’ racing hearts is a publish button. And the writer should be the one to click it.

[...]

Over the course of our conversation, Tsotsis told me she viewed the act of writing the post as a sort of meta-comment on The New York Times’ antiquated editorial structure: “Look what I can do with my dumb little WordPress blog. You guys can’t do this. Watch,” she remembered thinking.

Andrew Beaujon @ Poynter

Whether you love or hate Alexia Tsotsis’ writing, one thing is certainly true: she’s no one’s monkey. And while a debate about the wisdom of making “Fuckers” the first word of a blog post would undoubtedly be entertaining, that’s not what I want to talk about. Tsotsis and Beaujon make two very interesting points that directly relate to WordPress and its effect on publishing.

WordPress is absolutely a tool that can (and given the state of the tools they were previously using, should) be used by Ye Olde Media Guarde. We’ve even made some steps toward supporting a basic editorial workflow with the Contributor role (which can submit posts for review, but not publish them). But using WordPress in that way is like using a computer to print a letter and then fax it to your recipient. It feels like an artificial restriction. We’ve empowered individuals to publish what they want to publish, when they want to publish. Reinstating the print media workflows of the last century very much feels like a step backwards. Writers got a taste of true publishing freedom. Readers got a taste of what it’s like to actually have a connection and conversation with a writer instead of just being delivered their words. We can’t pretend that didn’t happen.

One of WordPress’ user experience breaks from its competitors was its “Publish” button. Other software had a “Save” button and then a drop-down status selector. So you’d select “Published” from the status drop-down, and then hit “Save”. With WordPress, your post is always one quick click away from being shared with the entire world. It’s more raw, more immediate, and more emotionally satisfying. WordPress also instituted “Edit” links on the front end, which gave the same sense of immediacy to the updating process. As much as the old media has embraced blogging as part of their publishing strategy, they’ve not fully integrated its responsive and update-able nature. On the whole, old media “blog posts” feel like a place where statements of questionable truth go to die and never be corrected, clarified, or amended.

Web publishing is much, much more than print publishing with the web as a distribution network. As long as the old media treats the web as a pipe instead of an opportunity to modernize the way they publish, they’ll continue to be called “the old media”.

BRB. Leaving a voicemail with my editor so she can get this post published in tomorrow’s issue.

14 thoughts on ““The writer should be the one to click it”

  1. It amazes me how every tiny element is so intentional. I started with WP and didn’t know that previous / other software had a ‘save’ button instead of publish. I will now be grateful that I can be impulsive and immediate. :)

  2. As a former Quark wizard, in a previous life, that involved temping in and around Boston, I can really embrace WordPress’s fondness for typography. I spent the last 5 years designing web sites for clueless clients before my husband got an IT job and freed me up for writing or painting or whatever… but, no one expects the Spanish Inquisition to come in the form of 4 Siberian Huskies!

    I tried blogging about their antics on another service and eventually gave up. It felt like a toy, I love WP it feels so grown up and it is so comfortable. I can go from my iPod touch to a slideshow of their latest destruction within minutes. And it looks so clean and professional! Within no time at all I have 3 blogs going and a real desire to get back into programming! WP is a slippery slope!

    I think I might even be able to unload my few remaining clients onto a WP site, that will help me sleep at night!

  3. Doug Ford says:

    The function of the “Publish” button should be configurable. It is far too easy in WP to publish instead of save when it’s tired out, and the damage and embarrassment can be great.

  4. We really appreciate the feedback and the kind words. You’ve been with us a long time and we’ve definitely enjoyed helping your business grow. We look forward to working with you for several years to come!

  5. WordPress also gives developing writers a chance to be heard… to click “publish” and feel as if one can reach like minded people across the world without the constraints of external filters is a glimpse into where the “new media” is headed.

    Thank you for your insight!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s